Wikipedia: point / counterpoint
While I whole-heartedly disagree with the premise of the former, I don't think the latter is very well-argued. I feel that the author personalizes far too much and resorts to hyperbole with distressing frequency. Nonetheless, he points out some real holes in the first article and adds some interesting paragraphs at the end regarding organizational models. Worth a read.
Actually, the Slashdot commentary on the article has some excellent points. (I know. I can't believe I just typed that, either. Just be sure to read at Comments +3)